ArchWiki:Reports

This table is used to report questionable edits as described in ArchWiki:Maintenance Team. Please use the talk page for discussing reports.

Diff	Timestamp	Type	Notes
Benchmarking	2011-12-09 19:10:07	style	personal comment (see also talk page)
Start_X_at_Boot	2011-11-02 13:26:24	content	pressing Ctrl+c just logs out because of exec
OpenFOAM	2011-12-10 20:01:19	style	new article, needs standard header
Intel_C%2B%2B	2011-12-04 13:33:14	style	warnings are notes actually?
Arch_Build_System	2011-12-07 02:28:32	style	pacman instructions (rm other occurrences)
Arch_Build_System	2011-12-07 03:08:51	content	content removed?
Lostfiles	2011-11-28 12:10:53	content	lost useful content?
JHBuild	2011-12-16 02:16:43	style	personal comments, installation instructions
Laptop	2011-12-16 20:17:53	content	check major change
Install_bundled_32-bit_system_in_Arch64	2011-11-22 23:18:57	content	check major edit - unexplained removal of content
SSH_Keys	2011-12-19 22:40:26	content	check major changes
Configuring_Network	2011-12-22 10:15:28	content	check not-so-obvious edits
OpenVPN	2011-12-29 18:46:48	style	html comments
DSDT	2012-01-01 16:26:48	content	check removed content
DualScreen	2012-01-04 09:18:27	style	credits, 1st level headings
Xfce	2012-01-06 12:48:36	content	should first look if there is a package for that theme, and also consider whether creating a PKGBUILD before extracting to /usr/share/icons
Default_Applications	2012-01-08 11:59:01	content	check major edits
Xcompmgr	2012-01-08 16:37:49	style	using first person
DeveloperWiki%3ABuilding_in_a_Clean_Chroot	2012-01-08 18:18:32	style	removed prompts: ok if in developerwiki?
GParted	2012-01-09 16:52:44	content	these instructions should better be moved to the PolicyKit article
MacBook_Pro_8,1_/_8,2_/_8,3_(2011_Macbook_Pro)	2012-01-10 17:43:14	style	explicit module instructions
Avant_Window_Navigator	2012-01-10 19:49:31	style	summary used as introduction
Ubuntu_One	2012-01-10 20:18:24	style	summary used as introduction
Libcanberra	2012-01-10 20:46:25	style	summary used as introduction
Syslinux	2012-01-10 21:38:32	style	note style, orthography
Dell_Wireless_1390	2012-01-11 07:05:19	content	lost some possibly useful content?
CVS_Server	2012-01-11 08:46:48	content	after a very quick comparison with the redirection target, some content may have been lost, verify
Lighttpd_for_SSL_and_non-SSL	2012-01-11 07:57:21	content	check
DeveloperWiki:Building_in_a_Clean_Chroot	2012-01-15 13:44:17	style	installation instructions
GRUB2	2012-01-15 16:43:49	style	using note instead of expansion template
Pacman_Tips	2012-01-17 13:46:39	content	check major edit, lost some useful content? not compatible with pacman 4? at least RepoSearch has been orphanized
Suspending_to_Disk_with_hibernate-script	2012-01-21 08:23:55	content	swap-offset doesn't seem to be mentioned in the linked section (lost content?)
D_(programming_language)	2012-01-24 20:04:14	style	installation instructions, note template, the article needs more style improvements
Herbstluftwm	2012-01-26 19:04:37	style	fix style
Installing_Arch_Linux_in_VMware	2012-01-28 21:16:26	content	check major edit, unexplained removal of content
VMware	2012-01-28 20:58:56	content	check major edit, unexplained removal of content
PeerGuardian_Linux	2012-01-29 16:39:26	content	why?
Kernel_Compilation%2FTraditional	2012-02-02 20:45:12	style	comments next to cli commands, used in the whole page
CD_Burning	2012-02-04 02:32:03	style	1st person, note template
Rlocate	2012-02-04 21:14:09	style	note
Archiso_as_pxe_server	2012-02-05 17:41:19	content	a similar edit was undid with https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php?title=Archiso_as_pxe_server&action=historysubmit&diff=142318&oldid=142302
Archiso	2012-02-05 17:40:03	content	verify if in this case -Sy is actually needed
DeveloperWiki:KDE	2012-02-05 17:39:23	content	there's the possibility that -Sy was used to first upgrade kde and then the entire system (in that case the edit should be undone and a pacman -Su command should be added)
Autodl-irssi	2012-02-07 09:01:23	style	pacman -Sy, however the article needs a lot of style improvements
Fonts	2012-02-08 18:01:22	content	relevance? this requires that the recipient of the message has the same font installed, which is quite unlikely
PulseAudio	2012-02-09 21:23:03	content	check major unexplained edit; some content has been moved to PulseAudio Examples; note tha use of "PKG" instead of "package"
PulseAudio/Examples	2012-02-10 21:32:21	content	doesn't explain the removal of an entire section
USB_Installation_Media	2012-02-10 22:39:50	content	what about free choice? should probably be discussed, something's already in the talk page but it's old and not very helpful
USB_Installation_Media	2012-02-11 20:18:26	style	follows [1], already reported i this table; instead of that link, probably the link to unetbootin from the parent section should be moved in this subsection
Beginners%27_Guide/Installation	2012-02-11 15:40:02	style	now the paragraph has too many repetitions of words (wish, instead...) may need some rewording
Beginners%27_Guide/Installation	2012-02-11 15:15:48	style	reword
Starcraft2	2012-02-13 15:17:48	style	<pre>
NetworkManager	2012-02-14 13:35:40	style	use note template
Msmtp	2012-02-15 10:34:48	style	installation instructions
Fprint	2012-02-15 20:05:43	style	installation instructions (including yaourt)
NVIDIA	2012-02-16 20:28:22	style	using 1st person
Audacious	2012-02-19 16:09:43	style	inst. instructions (normal user?)
Pidgin	2012-02-20 18:35:48	style	installation instructions
MacBook_Pro_8,1_/_8,2_/_8,3_(2011_Macbook_Pro)	2012-02-22 23:13:09	style	yaourt, sudo
Fonts	2012-02-23 09:08:54	content	ttf-kochi-substituteAUR doesn't seem unmaintained, it also has 146 votes
Sawfish	2012-02-25 11:33:37	style	yaourt
Xen	2012-02-28 07:17:33	style	use warning template
VMware	2012-02-28 22:48:22	style	use template
Lotus_Notes_in_32bit_Chroot	2012-03-01 19:56:52	style	aur link
Unison	2012-03-01 19:39:46	style	aur link
Asus_Zenbook_UX31E	2012-03-01 15:49:00	style	aur links
Shutdown_Pressing_Power_Button	2012-03-01 15:27:00	content	merge with the already existing Xfce section?
HAL	2012-03-02 21:11:03	content	"deinstallation" instructions, keep?
KVM	2012-03-03 14:09:19	content	unexplained removal
USB_Installation_Media	2012-03-03 17:01:58	content	follows [2] already reported in this table: what's so wrong with unetbootin?
WeTab	2012-03-04 01:59:56	style	Box RED is a meta template, consider using a warning or expansion or both
Lenovo_ThinkPad_T420	2012-03-04 12:25:03	style	DAEMONS example
Pro_Audio	2012-03-04 18:50:46	content	what about "ladish"?
USB_Installation_Media	2012-03-05 05:32:19	content	this edit removes unetbootin completely, but the project seems still alive... see the other several reports about this article
HDAPS	2012-03-06 22:16:26	style	daemon instructions, <br>
KEYMAP	2012-03-06 15:59:28	style	html list instead of wiki markup (fix also the table above)
Wine_PKGBUILD_guidelines	2012-03-10 09:01:18	style	direct aur links
Matlab	2012-03-12 14:15:59	style	writing in 1st person
Migrating_Between_Architectures_Without_Reinstalling	2012-03-12 14:17:50	style	using "edit:" is bad style, should probably be solved with status templates
Configuring_Network	2012-02-27 10:16:45	content	why the first part has been removed?
Linux-pf	2012-03-21 20:44:24	style	aur link
Microsoft_Office_2007	2012-03-21 19:15:42	style	probably needs a rewording
Oracle_client	2012-03-26 09:25:19	content	syncing w/o upgrading
SHA_password_hashes	2012-03-26 15:15:31	content	I think also the SHA password hashes#Benefits of SHA-2 over MD5 section should be updated, and the note at the top of the article was added with [3] together with the out of date template, it should probably be rewritten
Arduino	2012-03-29 02:25:10	content	still mention the "arduino" package as an alternative?
Emacs	2012-04-05 18:25:40	style	installation instructions, aur links
UMID_SE	2012-04-06 12:12:57	content	pacman -Sy
Archiso	2012-04-05 18:20:59	content	removed section may be useful for somebody, though perhaps more suited for USB_Installation_Media?
Archiso	2012-04-05 19:12:13	content	why remove the "mkinitcpio.conf" section and leave "aitab" and "Boot Loader" even if all of them say the default files are ok?
Advanced_Linux_Sound_Architecture	2012-04-06 15:22:41	content	do we want to display always the easiest way only, or display various choices and let the user choose?
ABS_FAQ	2012-04-11 18:32:39	content	mv deleted content to Arch Build System?
Virtual_Private_Server	2012-04-13 05:54:36	content	the recategorization should be discussed/justified better
Systemd%2FServices	2012-04-15 18:41:37	content	probably doing the opposite would be better? leaving the services code in the subpage and referencing them from the main article?
Solid_State_Drives	2012-04-15 21:38:12	content	why unsubstantiated? at least the link for the warning does make some sense (I haven't verified if it's an official document); the accuracy flag was added with [4] and the related discussion seems to end with the recommendation to remove a warning which has been left instead
Beginners%27_Guide%2FPost-Installation	2012-04-16 19:25:04	content	too informal, news are mentioned too specifically (will get out of date quickly) and, again, news are already mentioned in the "Update the System" section; partly discussed here
Bitcoin	2012-04-16 17:48:01	content	must comply w/ style guide and mention the various bitcoin packages (2 at the time of writing this)
Optical_Character_Recognition	2012-04-17 12:21:05	content	community packages go at the top?
Simple_Stateful_Firewall	2012-04-20 21:56:35	content	fix usage or rewrite according to the style guide
HP_ProBook_4530s	2012-04-26 11:12:24	style	installation instructions
DNSSEC	2012-05-01 05:20:02	style	use package templates (the whole article needs them)
Beginners%27_Guide/Installation	2012-05-02 01:25:00	content	if we want to support IPv6 (which seems fair) the whole section should be revisited, not just those lines, otherwise it may just create confusion
User-mode_Linux	2012-05-02 08:52:20	content	the DAEMONS array without `!hotplug` doesn't make sense anymore, the whole article should be adaptaed to the style rules; NOTE that `pacman -Sy` seems correct in this case
ASUS_N55SF	2012-05-03 01:59:01	style	use note template, maybe also rewrite avoiding first-person statements
E4rat	2012-05-03 22:14:31	content	the removed text did contain quite a good and instructive explanation, I don't know if it can just be dropped as FUD, unless it's proved that the latest version of e4rat solves the problem
LXDM	2012-04-29T21:59	content	Sentence not complete.
Thunar	2012-05-15 08:23:28	style	pacman instructions, the article has some other besides these
Migrating_Between_Architectures_Without_Reinstalling	2012-05-17 09:56:45	content	I think `pacman -Sw --needed` would work just fine
Open_Sound_System	2012-05-18 20:03:29	content	that's surely the wrong place to put installation instructions for volwheel, however I don't know where to move them at the moment
Nginx	2012-05-19 06:11:46	content	check major unexplained edit with removal of content
Syslinux	2012-05-23 08:41:07	content	is it so important to tell what applications _don't_ do, even in the introduction?
Firefox	2012-05-23 08:12:12	content	I don't know if that's the proper place to put that, and according to MS Fonts there are more up-to-date packages
Pacman-key	2012-05-23 05:42:23	content	I'm not sure long copy-paste commands are suited especially for this page
Beginners%27_Guide/Installation	2012-05-23 00:25:23	content	is that section becoming too detailed for an installation guide? what about moving something to specific articles?
PCManFM	2012-05-24 19:28:51	content	well, I don't use pcmanfm but I'd like to test this one, since (almost?) all DMs are CK-capable and such a command may even break CK, as is written in other articles
Go_Package_Guidelines	2012-05-26 06:01:00	content	unexplained removal of content (the article is probably watched by User:Trontonic, however I'm reporting this for doubt's sake
List_of_Qt4_applications	2012-05-28 23:13:24	content	bad package name, however there are some with similar names and I don't know which is the right one at the moment
Streaming_media	2012-05-30 05:13:44	content	some references e.g. to the AUR package seem to have been lost in the move
Pacman-key	2012-06-27 13:20:02	content	well that's indeed init agnostic, however the daemon should be mentioned anyway in accordance with Help:Style#Daemon operations?
PCManFM	2012-07-02 01:30:48	content	"sometimes"? he's probably using slim or another DM that launches ck and dbus by itself
ATI	2012-07-08 11:44:51	content	I tend to be suspicious of this kind of edits/justifications, maybe it requires investigation (also note it's just the author's second edit)