Domain name resolution: Difference between revisions

From ArchWiki
(→‎Resolvers: update expansion template, dingo is already mentioned in #Third-party DNS servers)
Line 109: Line 109:
* {{App|opennic-up|Automates the renewal of the DNS servers with the most responsive OpenNIC servers|https://github.com/kewlfft/opennic-up|{{AUR|opennic-up}}}}
* {{App|opennic-up|Automates the renewal of the DNS servers with the most responsive OpenNIC servers|https://github.com/kewlfft/opennic-up|{{AUR|opennic-up}}}}


== Resolvers ==
=== Resolver performance ===


{{Expansion|Cover DNS servers in general.|section=Covering DNS servers in general}}
The Glibc resolver does not cache queries. If you want local caching use [[systemd-resolved]] or set up a local caching [[#DNS servers|DNS server]] and use {{ic|127.0.0.1}} as your name server.
 
{{Expansion|Fill in the unknowns.}}
 
The Glibc resolver provides only the most basic necessities, it does not cache queries nor provides any security features. If you require more functionality, use another resolver.


{{Tip|
{{Tip|
* The ''drill'' or ''dig'' [[#Lookup utilities|lookup utilities]] report the query time.
* The ''drill'' or ''dig'' [[#Lookup utilities|lookup utilities]] report the query time.
* A router usually sets its own caching resolver as the network's DNS server thus providing DNS cache for the whole network.
* A router usually sets its own caching resolver as the network's DNS server thus providing DNS cache for the whole network.  
* If it takes too long to switch to the next DNS server you can try [[#Limit lookup time|decreasing the timeout]].
* If it takes too long to switch to the next DNS server you can try [[#Limit lookup time|decreasing the timeout]].}}
}}
 
=== DNS servers ===


In the table below, the columns have the following meaning:  
[[DNS]] servers can be [[Wikipedia:Authoritative name server|authoritative]] and [[Wikipedia:Name server#Recursive query|recursive]]. If they are neither, they are called '''stub resolvers''' and simply forward all queries to another recursive name server. Stub resolvers are typically used to introduce DNS caching on the local host or network. Note that the same can also be achieved with a fully-fledged name server. This section compares the available DNS servers, for a more detailed comparison, refer to [[Wikipedia:Comparison of DNS server software|Wikipedia]].


* ''Cache'': [[Wikipedia:Name server#Caching name server|caches]] the DNS queries to improve lookup times of subsequent identical requests.
{{Expansion|Fill in the unknowns. Add {{AUR|deadwood}}.}}
* ''Recursor'': can [[Wikipedia:Name server#Recursive query|recursively query]] the domain name starting from the [[Wikipedia:DNS root zone|DNS root zone]].
* ''resolvconf compatibility'': can acquire name servers and search domains, to use for forwarding requests, from software that sets them using [[resolvconf]].
* ''Validates DNSSEC'': [[Wikipedia:Domain Name System Security Extensions#The lookup procedure|validates]] DNS query responses using [[DNSSEC]].
* ''DNS over TLS'': supports forwarding using the [[Wikipedia:DNS over TLS|DNS over TLS]] protocol.
* ''DNS over HTTPS'': supports forwarding using the [[Wikipedia:DNS over HTTPS|DNS over HTTPS]] protocol.


{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align:center"
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align:center"
! Resolver !! Cache !! Recursor !! ''resolvconf'' compatibility !!  Validates DNSSEC !! DNS over TLS !! DNS over HTTPS
! Name !! Package !! [[Wikipedia:Authoritative name server|Authoritative]]<br>/ [[Wikipedia:Name server#Recursive query|Recursive]] !! [[Wikipedia:Name server#Caching name server|Cache]] !! [[resolvconf]] !!  [[Wikipedia:Domain Name System Security Extensions#The lookup procedure|Validates]]<br>[[DNSSEC]] !! [[Wikipedia:DNS over TLS|DNS<br>over TLS]] !! [[Wikipedia:DNS over HTTPS|DNS<br>over HTTPS]]
|-
|-
! [[#Glibc resolver|glibc]]
! [[dnscrypt-proxy]]<sup>1</sup>
| {{No}} || {{No}} || {{G|[[openresolv]]}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}}
| {{Pkg|dnscrypt-proxy}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}}
|-
|-
! [[BIND]]
! [[Rescached]]
| {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[openresolv]] subscriber}} || {{Yes}} || ? || ?
| {{AUR|rescached-git}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes|https://github.com/shuLhan/rescached-go#integration-with-openresolv}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Y|Limited}}<sup>2</sup>
|-
! [[Stubby]]
| {{Pkg|stubby}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}}
|-
|-
! [[dnscrypt-proxy]]<sup>1</sup>
!style="white-space: nowrap;"| [[systemd-resolved]]
| {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}}
| {{Pkg|systemd}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[systemd-resolvconf|Yes]]}} || {{Yes}} || {{Y|Insecure}}<sup>3</sup> || {{No|https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/8639}}
|-
|-
! [[dnsmasq]]
! [[dnsmasq]]
| {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{G|[[openresolv]] subscriber}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|http://lists.thekelleys.org.uk/pipermail/dnsmasq-discuss/2018q2/012131.html}} || {{No}}
| {{Pkg|dnsmasq}} || {{Y|Partial}}<sup>4</sup> || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[openresolv#Subscribers|Yes]]}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|http://lists.thekelleys.org.uk/pipermail/dnsmasq-discuss/2018q2/012131.html}} || {{No}}
|-
! [[BIND]]
| {{Pkg|bind}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[openresolv#Subscribers|Yes]]}} || {{Yes}} || ? || ?
|-
|-
! [[Knot Resolver]]
! [[Knot Resolver]]
| {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|https://gitlab.labs.nic.cz/knot/knot-resolver/issues/243}}
| {{AUR|knot-resolver}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|https://gitlab.labs.nic.cz/knot/knot-resolver/issues/243}}
|-
! [[Wikipedia:MaraDNS|MaraDNS]]
| {{AUR|maradns}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}}
|-
|-
! [[pdnsd]]
! [[pdnsd]]
| {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[openresolv]] subscriber}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}}
| {{Pkg|pdnsd}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|Permanent}} || {{G|[[openresolv#Subscribers|Yes]]}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}}
|-
|-
! {{Pkg|powerdns-recursor}}
! [https://www.powerdns.com/recursor.html PowerDNS Recursor]
| {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|https://roy.marples.name/projects/openresolv/config#pdns_recursor}} || {{Yes}} || ? || ?
| {{Pkg|powerdns-recursor}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|https://roy.marples.name/projects/openresolv/config#pdns_recursor}} || {{Yes}} || ? || ?
|-
! [[Rescached]]
| {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{G|[[openresolv]] subscriber}}<sup>2</sup> || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Y|Limited}}<sup>3</sup>
|-
! [[Stubby]]
| {{No}} || {{No}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}}
|-
!style="white-space: nowrap;"| [[systemd-resolved]]
| {{Yes}} || {{No}} || {{G|[[systemd-resolvconf]]}} || {{Yes}} || {{Y|Insecure}}<sup>4</sup> || {{No|https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/8639}}
|-
|-
! [[Unbound]]
! [[Unbound]]
| {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[openresolv]] subscriber}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|1=https://nlnetlabs.nl/bugs-script/show_bug.cgi?id=1200}}
| {{Pkg|unbound}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{G|[[openresolv#Subscribers|Yes]]}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}} || {{No|1=https://nlnetlabs.nl/bugs-script/show_bug.cgi?id=1200}}
|}
|}


# Implements a [[Wikipedia:DNSCrypt|DNSCrypt]] protocol client.
# Implements a [[Wikipedia:DNSCrypt|DNSCrypt]] protocol client.
# Can use the subscribers of dnsmasq, pdns and unbound.[https://github.com/shuLhan/rescached-go#integration-with-openresolv]
# Only forwards using DNS over HTTPS when Rescached itself is queried using DNS over HTTPS.[https://github.com/shuLhan/rescached-go#integration-with-dns-over-https]
# Only forwards using DNS over HTTPS when Rescached itself is queried using DNS over HTTPS.[https://github.com/shuLhan/rescached-go#integration-with-dns-over-https]
# From {{man|5|resolved.conf}}: ''Note as the resolver is not capable of authenticating the server, it is vulnerable for "man-in-the-middle" attacks.''[https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/9397] Also, the only supported mode is "opportunistic", which ''makes DNS-over-TLS vulnerable to "downgrade" attacks''.[https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/10755]
# From {{man|5|resolved.conf}}: ''Note as the resolver is not capable of authenticating the server, it is vulnerable for "man-in-the-middle" attacks.''[https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/9397] Also, the only supported mode is "opportunistic", which ''makes DNS-over-TLS vulnerable to "downgrade" attacks''.[https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/10755]
# From [[Wikipedia:Comparison_of_DNS_server_software#cite_note-masqauth-26|Wikipedia]]: dnsmasq has limited authoritative support, intended for internal network use rather than public Internet use.
==== Authoritative-only servers ====
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align:center"
! Name !! Package !!  [[DNSSEC]] !! Geographic<br>balancing
|-
! [https://gdnsd.org/ gdnsd]
| {{Pkg|gdnsd}} || {{No}} || {{Yes}}
|-
! [https://www.knot-dns.cz/ Knot DNS]
| {{Pkg|knot}} || {{Yes}} || {{No}}
|-
! [[NSD]]
| {{Pkg|nsd}} || {{No}} || {{No}}
|-
! [https://www.powerdns.com/auth.html PowerDNS]
| {{Pkg|powerdns}} || {{Yes}} || {{Yes}}
|}


== See also ==
== See also ==

Revision as of 17:08, 9 January 2019

In general, a domain name represents an IP address and is associated to it in the Domain Name System (DNS). This article explains how to configure domain name resolution and resolve domain names.

Name Service Switch

The Name Service Switch (NSS) facility is part of the GNU C Library (glibc) and backs the getaddrinfo(3) API, used to resolve domain names. NSS allows system databases to be provided by separate services, whose search order can be configured by the administrator in nsswitch.conf(5). The database responsible for domain name resolution is the hosts database, for which glibc offers the following services:

Systemd provides three NSS services for hostname resolution:

Resolve a domain name using NSS

NSS databases can be queried with getent(1). A domain name can be resolved through NSS using:

$ getent hosts domain_name
Note: While most programs resolve domain names using NSS, some may read /etc/resolv.conf and/or /etc/hosts directly. See Network configuration#Local hostname resolution.

Glibc resolver

The glibc resolver reads /etc/resolv.conf for every resolution to determine the nameservers and options to use.

resolv.conf(5) lists nameservers together with some configuration options. Nameservers listed first are tried first, up to three nameservers may be listed. Lines starting with a number sign (#) are ignored.

Note: The glibc resolver does not cache queries. To improve query lookup time you can set up a caching resolver. See #Resolvers for more information.

Overwriting of /etc/resolv.conf

Network managers tend to overwrite /etc/resolv.conf, for specifics see the corresponding section:

To prevent programs from overwriting /etc/resolv.conf you can also write-protect it by setting the immutable file attribute:

# chattr +i /etc/resolv.conf
Tip: If you want multiple processes to write to /etc/resolv.conf, you can use resolvconf.

Limit lookup time

If you are confronted with a very long hostname lookup (may it be in pacman or while browsing), it often helps to define a small timeout after which an alternative nameserver is used. To do so, put the following in /etc/resolv.conf.

options timeout:1

Hostname lookup delayed with IPv6

If you experience a 5 second delay when resolving hostnames it might be due to a DNS-server/Firewall misbehaving and only giving one reply to a parallel A and AAAA request.[1] You can fix that by setting the following option in /etc/resolv.conf:

options single-request

Local domain names

If you want to be able to use the hostname of local machine names without the fully qualified domain names, then add a line to /etc/resolv.conf with the local domain such as:

domain example.com

That way you can refer to local hosts such as mainmachine1.example.com as simply mainmachine1 when using the ssh command, but the drill command still requires the fully qualified domain names in order to perform lookups.

Lookup utilities

To query specific DNS servers and DNS/DNSSEC records you can use dedicated DNS lookup utilities. These tools implement DNS themselves and do not use NSS.

  • ldns provides drill(1), which is a tool designed to retrieve information out of the DNS.

For example, to query a specific nameserver with drill for the TXT records of a domain:

$ drill @nameserver TXT domain

If you do not specify a DNS server drill uses the nameservers defined in /etc/resolv.conf.

Privacy and security

The DNS protocol is unencrypted and does not account for confidentiality, integrity or authentication, so if you use an untrusted network or a malicious ISP, your DNS queries can be eavesdropped and the responses manipulated. Furthermore, DNS servers can conduct DNS hijacking.

You need to trust your DNS server to treat your queries confidentially. DNS servers are provided by ISPs and third-parties. Alternatively you can run your own recursive name server, which however takes more effort. If you use a DHCP client in untrusted networks, be sure to set static name servers to avoid using and being subject to arbitrary DNS servers. To secure your communication with a remote DNS server you can use an encrypted protocol, like DNS over TLS, DNS over HTTPS or DNSCrypt, provided that both the upstream server and your resolver support the protocol. To verify that responses are actually from authoritative name servers, you can validate DNSSEC, provided that both the upstream server(s) and your resolver support it.

Be aware that client software, such as major web browsers, may also (start to) implement some of the protocols. While the encryption of queries may often be seen as a bonus, it also means the software sidetracks queries around the system resolver configuration.[2]

Third-party DNS servers

Note: Before using a third-party DNS service, check its privacy policy for information on how user data is handled. User data has value and can be sold to other parties.

There are various third-party DNS services available, some of which also have dedicated software:

  • dingo — A DNS client for Google DNS over HTTPS
https://github.com/pforemski/dingo || dingo
  • opennic-up — Automates the renewal of the DNS servers with the most responsive OpenNIC servers
https://github.com/kewlfft/opennic-up || opennic-upAUR

Resolver performance

The Glibc resolver does not cache queries. If you want local caching use systemd-resolved or set up a local caching DNS server and use 127.0.0.1 as your name server.

Tip:
  • The drill or dig lookup utilities report the query time.
  • A router usually sets its own caching resolver as the network's DNS server thus providing DNS cache for the whole network.
  • If it takes too long to switch to the next DNS server you can try decreasing the timeout.

DNS servers

DNS servers can be authoritative and recursive. If they are neither, they are called stub resolvers and simply forward all queries to another recursive name server. Stub resolvers are typically used to introduce DNS caching on the local host or network. Note that the same can also be achieved with a fully-fledged name server. This section compares the available DNS servers, for a more detailed comparison, refer to Wikipedia.

This article or section needs expansion.

Reason: Fill in the unknowns. Add deadwoodAUR. (Discuss in Talk:Domain name resolution)
Name Package Authoritative
/ Recursive
Cache resolvconf Validates
DNSSEC
DNS
over TLS
DNS
over HTTPS
dnscrypt-proxy1 dnscrypt-proxy No Yes No No No Yes
Rescached rescached-gitAUR No Yes Yes No No Limited2
Stubby stubby No No No Yes Yes No
systemd-resolved systemd No Yes Yes Yes Insecure3 No
dnsmasq dnsmasq Partial4 Yes Yes Yes No No
BIND bind Yes Yes Yes Yes ? ?
Knot Resolver knot-resolverAUR Yes Yes No Yes Yes No
MaraDNS maradnsAUR Yes Yes No No No No
pdnsd pdnsd Yes Permanent Yes No No No
PowerDNS Recursor powerdns-recursor Yes Yes No Yes ? ?
Unbound unbound Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
  1. Implements a DNSCrypt protocol client.
  2. Only forwards using DNS over HTTPS when Rescached itself is queried using DNS over HTTPS.[3]
  3. From resolved.conf(5): Note as the resolver is not capable of authenticating the server, it is vulnerable for "man-in-the-middle" attacks.[4] Also, the only supported mode is "opportunistic", which makes DNS-over-TLS vulnerable to "downgrade" attacks.[5]
  4. From Wikipedia: dnsmasq has limited authoritative support, intended for internal network use rather than public Internet use.

Authoritative-only servers

Name Package DNSSEC Geographic
balancing
gdnsd gdnsd No Yes
Knot DNS knot Yes No
NSD nsd No No
PowerDNS powerdns Yes Yes

See also